2 Years of Ringfencing
Printed From: National League Rugby Discussion Forum
Category: League Rugby - www.leaguerugby.co.uk
Forum Name: The Championship
Forum Description: Discuss the 12 clubs forming the English Championship.
URL: http://www.leaguerugby.co.uk/forum_posts.asp?TID=19690
Printed Date: 15 Nov 2024 at 07:40 Software Version: Web Wiz Forums 12.04 - http://www.webwizforums.com
Topic: 2 Years of Ringfencing
Posted By: The Blues
Subject: 2 Years of Ringfencing
Date Posted: 11 Mar 2023 at 18:30
And now the worst England defeat in the 4, 5, 6 Nations ever, 3rd worst ever and worst at home… good job one of the arguments for Ringfencing is that it would benefit the National team, as otherwise we could have been looking at a 100 point defeat!
|
Replies:
Posted By: One For The Ditch
Date Posted: 11 Mar 2023 at 19:30
A very poor performance. Where is the value for the tens of millions that are spent to secure players for England representation??
|
Posted By: corporalcarrot
Date Posted: 11 Mar 2023 at 19:33
France were really good today. England didn't get close. Proper rugby teams don't panic but learn why the opposition team beat us and move on. The RFU seem to have a problem in accepting that they haven't got it right yet. Recognising that the chip on their shoulder is premiership rugby in its existing form might be worth considering .................
------------- Dont kick it. Pick it up and GO FORWARD.
|
Posted By: greenpower
Date Posted: 11 Mar 2023 at 19:38
it was so much worse than poor i pity all the fans who paid to watch that sh-te theres no pace outwide no power up front no direction just endless pathetic box kicks not a england team that will worry anybody at the forthcoming world cup
|
Posted By: corporalcarrot
Date Posted: 11 Mar 2023 at 20:25
greenpower wrote:
it was so much worse than poor i pity all the fans who paid to watch that sh-te theres no pace outwide no power up front no direction just endless pathetic box kicks not a england team that will worry anybody at the forthcoming world cup | If you pick a best of team from that match how many would be English & how many would be French.
------------- Dont kick it. Pick it up and GO FORWARD.
|
Posted By: greenpower
Date Posted: 11 Mar 2023 at 20:44
none of the english players would merit been in the best team infact none of them would get into a welsh team if they could they were that bad
|
Posted By: Deva Delinquent
Date Posted: 11 Mar 2023 at 20:57
That was easily the worst performance I have ever seen from England.
France dominated from start to finish and never looked like giving up their lead. They were hungry, chased every half chance and were rewarded with a record win against a toothless England side.
To top it all off I had to drive because of the unreliability of the trains 🤬
|
Posted By: carlos fandango
Date Posted: 12 Mar 2023 at 08:38
As a friend of mine said, it was like watching a 3rd team play a first team. The first team scored whenever it wanted.
|
Posted By: rugbychris
Date Posted: 12 Mar 2023 at 09:35
I was one of the poor souls who paid £122 a ticket and £7 a pint. France were excellent but Englad were totally listless. No aggression, no encouragement nothing. If they go down battling then fine. But to rollover without firing a shot is embarrassing.
|
Posted By: One For The Ditch
Date Posted: 12 Mar 2023 at 09:48
rugbychris wrote:
I was one of the poor souls who paid £122 a ticket and £7 a pint. France were excellent but Englad were totally listless. No aggression, no encouragement nothing. If they go down battling then fine. But to rollover without firing a shot is embarrassing.
|
Hopefully the beer was more enjoyable than the Rugby even at that price!
|
Posted By: Camquin
Date Posted: 12 Mar 2023 at 10:07
Did France excel, or were they merely competent?
Would any of their tries make the highlights reel for National 1? Every week, excitable commentators praise basic skill as being "superb". So everyone is world-class - until they are exposed.
------------- Sweeney Delenda Est
|
Posted By: *Stalwart
Date Posted: 12 Mar 2023 at 10:08
rugbychris wrote:
I was one of the poor souls who paid £122 a ticket and £7 a pint. France were excellent but Englad were totally listless. No aggression, no encouragement nothing. If they go down battling then fine. But to rollover without firing a shot is embarrassing.
|
I feel your pain. £122 is ridiculous. Not long before people start voting with their feet.
------------- *Stalwart
|
Posted By: KnightsBoy
Date Posted: 12 Mar 2023 at 10:17
*Stalwart wrote:
rugbychris wrote:
I was one of the poor souls who paid £122 a ticket and £7 a pint. France were excellent but Englad were totally listless. No aggression, no encouragement nothing. If they go down battling then fine. But to rollover without firing a shot is embarrassing.
|
I feel your pain. £122 is ridiculous. Not long before people start voting with their feet. |
I voted with my feet away from Twickenham years ago, too expensive for your working class lad
|
Posted By: Kimbo
Date Posted: 12 Mar 2023 at 13:10
KnightsBoy wrote:
*Stalwart wrote:
rugbychris wrote:
I was one of the poor souls who paid £122 a ticket and £7 a pint. France were excellent but Englad were totally listless. No aggression, no encouragement nothing. If they go down battling then fine. But to rollover without firing a shot is embarrassing.
|
I feel your pain. £122 is ridiculous. Not long before people start voting with their feet. |
I voted with my feet away from Twickenham years ago, too expensive for your working class lad |
Me too. Awful ground, awful experience, and it seems awful team. Nothing would tempt me back there short of Cov being in a game.
------------- Our City, Our Club
|
Posted By: RedPete
Date Posted: 12 Mar 2023 at 14:07
Kimbo wrote:
KnightsBoy wrote:
*Stalwart wrote:
rugbychris wrote:
I was one of the poor souls who paid £122 a ticket and £7 a pint. France were excellent but Englad were totally listless. No aggression, no encouragement nothing. If they go down battling then fine. But to rollover without firing a shot is embarrassing.
|
I feel your pain. £122 is ridiculous. Not long before people start voting with their feet. |
I voted with my feet away from Twickenham years ago, too expensive for your working class lad |
Me too. Awful ground, awful experience, and it seems awful team. Nothing would tempt me back there short of Cov being in a game. |
Me too. Not much chance of Taunton appearing there but might go to see Somerset play there in the County Championship!
------------- Don't let the perfect be the enemy of the good.
|
Posted By: tigerburnie
Date Posted: 12 Mar 2023 at 14:17
The PRL ring fencing has nothing to do with the RFU's ineptitude, they were wrong to hire Jones, they were wrong not to get rid of him after the last world cup, they were wrong getting rid of him just before this world cup and they will blame Borthwick for not having a magic wand.
|
Posted By: corporalcarrot
Date Posted: 12 Mar 2023 at 14:24
Kimbo wrote:
KnightsBoy wrote:
*Stalwart wrote:
rugbychris wrote:
I was one of the poor souls who paid £122 a ticket and £7 a pint. France were excellent but Englad were totally listless. No aggression, no encouragement nothing. If they go down battling then fine. But to rollover without firing a shot is embarrassing.
|
I feel your pain. £122 is ridiculous. Not long before people start voting with their feet. |
I voted with my feet away from Twickenham years ago, too expensive for your working class lad |
Me too. Awful ground, awful experience, and it seems awful team. Nothing would tempt me back there short of Cov being in a game. | I would go back to see Jersey play Amps in a playoff final. http://news.bbc.co.uk/local/jersey/hi/people_and_places/newsid_8677000/8677351.stm" rel="nofollow - BBC - Following Jersey to Twickenham
------------- Dont kick it. Pick it up and GO FORWARD.
|
Posted By: Fat Albert
Date Posted: 12 Mar 2023 at 16:48
England's worst ever defeat at Twickenham (53-10) had Steve Borthwick as head coach
Guess who was captain when England suffered their second biggest defeat (6-42 Nov 22,2008) at HQ?
------------- a Freudian slip is when you say one thing but mean your mother
|
Posted By: Fat Albert
Date Posted: 12 Mar 2023 at 16:52
corporalcarrot wrote:
I would go back to see Jersey play Amps in a playoff final. http://news.bbc.co.uk/local/jersey/hi/people_and_places/newsid_8677000/8677351.stm" rel="nofollow - BBC - Following Jersey to Twickenham | I woz there, still sulking about the (non) penalty try
I haven't been back to HQ since (2013) I realised what Ian Ritchie was doing to the RFU... and it's only got worse since
------------- a Freudian slip is when you say one thing but mean your mother
|
Posted By: The Blues
Date Posted: 12 Mar 2023 at 21:00
In my first posting I forgot to add… France has invested in more than one division, England only has one division according to its governing body!
|
Posted By: Brizzer
Date Posted: 12 Mar 2023 at 21:24
Fat Albert wrote:
corporalcarrot wrote:
I would go back to see Jersey play Amps in a playoff final. http://news.bbc.co.uk/local/jersey/hi/people_and_places/newsid_8677000/8677351.stm" rel="nofollow - BBC - Following Jersey to Twickenham | I woz there, still sulking about the (non) penalty tryÂ
I haven't been back to HQ since (2013) I realised what Ian Ritchie was doing to the RFU... and it's only got worse since | I was also there Fat Albert. What an incredible day. I still can’t believe that we were there and that we won, especially with Ampthill camped on our line for much of the 2nd half.
------------- Tackle Low!!!!!
|
Posted By: Taffy
Date Posted: 13 Mar 2023 at 14:13
greenpower wrote:
none of the english players would merit been in the best team infact none of them would get into a welsh team if they could they were that bad |
|
Posted By: Cov kid 42
Date Posted: 13 Mar 2023 at 14:36
I truthfully cannot remember the last time I was at Twickenham watching England live. The rates they are now charging are plain ridiculous. Will happily join Kimbo to see my faithful Cov there;that is the limit.
------------- John Butler
|
Posted By: tigerburnie
Date Posted: 13 Mar 2023 at 15:06
Taffy wrote:
greenpower wrote:
none of the english players would merit been in the best team infact none of them would get into a welsh team if they could they were that bad |
|
I fixed that for you...........................
|
Posted By: Old Gold
Date Posted: 14 Mar 2023 at 14:09
I fixed that for you...........................
------------- #AClubForLife💛❤️🖤
|
Posted By: Mark Smith
Date Posted: 19 Mar 2023 at 19:35
Lack of relegation really seems to be hampering Ireland.
Grand Slams at senior and U20s levels.
|
Posted By: tigerburnie
Date Posted: 19 Mar 2023 at 20:50
Mark Smith wrote:
Lack of relegation really seems to be hampering Ireland.
Grand Slams at senior and U20s levels. |
You're comparing apples with banana's Markie, Falcons will have to pull their socks up they'll be in Prem 2 if they're not careful.......................................
|
Posted By: Camquin
Date Posted: 19 Mar 2023 at 21:09
Yes, but the regions have limits on the number of foreign players. They also have to make international players available for training, and rest them.
I believe Munster have six non-Irish players out of 44, including Healy, who played his junior rugby for Ireland before declaring for Scotland.
Bath have 22 foreign players, Exeter 28.
------------- Sweeney Delenda Est
|
Posted By: Geoff DC
Date Posted: 19 Mar 2023 at 21:21
Nice to see 'Ramshackle Smith' posting here again
|
Posted By: Brizzer
Date Posted: 19 Mar 2023 at 22:38
Geoff DC wrote:
Nice to see 'Ramshackle Smith' posting here again Â
| Speak for yourself
------------- Tackle Low!!!!!
|
Posted By: Kimbo
Date Posted: 20 Mar 2023 at 00:05
Posted By: Mark W-J
Date Posted: 20 Mar 2023 at 07:47
Mark Smith wrote:
Lack of relegation really seems to be hampering Ireland.
Grand Slams at senior and U20s levels. |
How's it working out for Italy and Wales, though...?
|
Posted By: The Blues
Date Posted: 20 Mar 2023 at 08:26
Mark Smith wrote:
Lack of relegation really seems to be hampering Ireland.
Grand Slams at senior and U20s levels. |
The issue is clubs at the bottom of the Premiership don’t invest… why… because they do not have to, they have no repercussions. Failure is rewarded, pressure matches are removed all the things that gave English players the edge in our more dominant days.
|
Posted By: Runitback
Date Posted: 20 Mar 2023 at 08:54
I honestly think you have to look at the governance of the game, it does not take a genius to see English and Welsh rugby in sharp decline. England used to dominate U20 rugby , rightly so, this fed through to the men’s senior team. The age groups are now not given priority, which they should. Strangely Ireland at both levels win grand slams and England and Wales both humbled by France.
The Premiership is poor, the Championship lacking identity and investment.
Surely time for change at HQ,Sweeney and OShea have totally mismanaged the game and they need to move on or we will continue this downward spiral !!!
------------- Run with it
|
Posted By: 'Hopper
Date Posted: 20 Mar 2023 at 10:44
Camquin wrote:
Bath have 22 foreign players, Exeter 28. |
Therewith lies the problem with the English National teams. Why nurture young talented players when you can simply import ready made models from overseas. English International Rugby is on the decline and will continue to do so whilst Premiership Clubs carry on in this manner. You only have to look at the English Soccer Premiership to see what has happened to their National team using this method of recruitment.
------------- What if the Hokey Kokey really IS what it's all about?
|
Posted By: billesleyexile
Date Posted: 20 Mar 2023 at 11:43
The Blues wrote:
Mark Smith wrote:
Lack of relegation really seems to be hampering Ireland.
Grand Slams at senior and U20s levels. |
The issue is clubs at the bottom of the Premiership don’t invest… why… because they do not have to, they have no repercussions. Failure is rewarded, pressure matches are removed all the things that gave English players the edge in our more dominant days. |
And all because no one at the RFU was brave enough (unlike in Ireland where the IRFU put Garryowen firmly back in their box) to tell the clubs in 1995 that the future was the Divisional game, controlled by the RFU. Fran Cotton was right.
------------- keep the faith
|
Posted By: kempstonblue
Date Posted: 20 Mar 2023 at 11:49
billesleyexile wrote:
The Blues wrote:
Mark Smith wrote:
Lack of relegation really seems to be hampering Ireland.
Grand Slams at senior and U20s levels. |
The issue is clubs at the bottom of the Premiership don’t invest… why… because they do not have to, they have no repercussions. Failure is rewarded, pressure matches are removed all the things that gave English players the edge in our more dominant days. |
And all because no one at the RFU was brave enough (unlike in Ireland where the IRFU put Garryowen firmly back in their box) to tell the clubs in 1995 that the future was the Divisional game, controlled by the RFU. Fran Cotton was right. |
The only thing is England has 4 Divisions.
Where would they have been placed?
The size of England would have required minimum of two teams in each Division or like today vast swathes of the country without a top flight rugby team, and like cricket no chance of having one.
Of course the bad management of the game has achieved a similar result.
------------- The older I get, the more the RFU leave me confused.
|
Posted By: billesleyexile
Date Posted: 20 Mar 2023 at 12:40
kempstonblue wrote:
billesleyexile wrote:
The Blues wrote:
Mark Smith wrote:
Lack of relegation really seems to be hampering Ireland.
Grand Slams at senior and U20s levels. |
The issue is clubs at the bottom of the Premiership don’t invest… why… because they do not have to, they have no repercussions. Failure is rewarded, pressure matches are removed all the things that gave English players the edge in our more dominant days. |
And all because no one at the RFU was brave enough (unlike in Ireland where the IRFU put Garryowen firmly back in their box) to tell the clubs in 1995 that the future was the Divisional game, controlled by the RFU. Fran Cotton was right. |
The only thing is England has 4 Divisions.
Where would they have been placed?
The size of England would have required minimum of two teams in each Division or like today vast swathes of the country without a top flight rugby team, and like cricket no chance of having one.
Of course the bad management of the game has achieved a similar result. |
Quite. Fran's plan IIRC was a small number of professional sides feeding a successful England team, and set up to put their interests below the national side's (and be controlled centrally) to that end. IIRC I think he envisaged matches being played around the grounds within the division, with the clubs continuing to operate underneath. So in the Midlands (of the mid 1990s) you might have had matches at Welford Road, Franklins Gardens, Goldington Road, Coundon Road and the Reddings, for example.
Wouldn't work now - there would be tears of rage from entitled premiership fans and owners for a start* - but in 1995, when crowds were smaller and no one knew what they were doing - it stood a chance of working IMO.
But obviously we are where we are. Part of me would enjoy watching the premiership clubs being told professional rugby was over for them though!
*and Wales left it too late before trying the same thing too, obviously.
------------- keep the faith
|
|